I purchased these shoes as an Easter gift for my granddaughter. She loved them They fit perfectly, not tight around the toes at all. I can't really rate the other comments you ask for because my granddaughter doesn't live near me. My comments are based on what my daughter has told me.
Capezio Girls 3800 Mary Jane Tap Shoe in Caramel - Size 11.5 M Toddlers
49 Review
Slip-Resistant Crib Shoes for Babies: Robeez Soft Soles for Girls and Unisex Toddlers, Ages 0-24 Months
53 Review
Adorable Blowfish Malibu Play-t for Toddler and Little Girls
47 Review
Stylish and Comfortable pediped Flex Estella Mary Jane Shoes for Toddlers and Little Kids
60 Review