Review on Cole Haan Crosscourt Sneaker Burnished Men's Shoes by Deelo Sylvester

First I bought a black pair in 11.5D and I really like them considering they won't last very long. Their soft skin is pleasant to the touch, but easily wrinkled and dirty. Anyway, I've ordered a second black pair and a third tan pair in the same size. To my surprise, these supposedly identical shoes had a completely different fit! The brown was much thicker and hard and uncomfortable to wear all day while the black was soft and comfortable in just a few hours. I thought I received the wrong size but the imprint on the inside indicated that both shoes are 11.5D. So I decided to measure them. You can see in the attached photos that while they are the same model from the same manufacturer or production line, they are not the same! This is the first time something like this has happened to me since I've bought hundreds of pairs of shoes! I'm worried it's not the original CH! Attention buyers! Something is "fishy" here!