I would give the shoes a 5 because they fit as expected and look very nice. My only issue is the flowers on the shoes - they had small rhinestones in the back tie and fell off when my daughters first put them on. I ordered 2 pairs, one for my 5 year old and another pair for my 2 year old. Both girls' rhinestones came off and they wore them to church on a Sunday morning where they did nothing but go for a walk and they wore them for a maximum of 3 hours - the 2 year old takes off her shoes as soon as we were in the Church are so that they can. "I had them for an hour total. If I could find the stones I would tape them back but they got lost. I bought new replacement flowers and the shoes are fine now. In terms of fit and wear and looks would i give 5 stars i would only recommend the manufacturers glue the stones better or you reinforce them yourself when you get them i could have just gotten two loose stones things might not be right my Girls aren't rough with dress shoes because we only wear them to church, and they like to take them off quickly since I'm not looking anyway, so I don't think the pebbles fell off because of the roughness.
Stylish and Comfortable pediped Flex Estella Mary Jane Shoes for Toddlers and Little Kids
60 Review
Slip-Resistant Crib Shoes for Babies: Robeez Soft Soles for Girls and Unisex Toddlers, Ages 0-24 Months
53 Review
Capezio Girls 3800 Mary Jane Tap Shoe in Caramel - Size 11.5 M Toddlers
49 Review
DREAM PAIRS Little Aurora 03 Communion Shoes and Flats for Girls - Top Choice for Stunning Style and Comfort
49 Review