I give 5 stars because I love the shoes. However. The right shoe is already falling apart and it took me 2 weeks to get them. I wear them to work and around the house. However, I think I need a size larger. That's why my broad foot is already on the side. I will buy a size up when I have the money and then give a full review. Again LOVE the shoes. The one on the left fits almost perfectly. The right one was too tight. Fine. I can now give a better review after having these shoes for 2 months. I still love these shoes so much. However, I would suggest checking the shoes after putting them on. I work in an office, so I'm not an active person. Little did I know there was a big hole in the big toe of my right foot. My shoes have never worn out so quickly. Again I sit down for life. Both shoes do the same thing. That's all I can say.