Review on Maybelline New York Washable Blackest Makeup : Eyes by Tim Armstrong

It's pretty good. What worries me the most is that I have short droopy lashes. Dramatic push-ups hold curls well after curling my lashes; it doesn't bother her. It also gives good volume, other lightweight mascaras don't give much volume. And finally, there's good length. Would consider buying this again, will try the push up version with dramatic wings next. Texture: Slightly damp but not too much 2.5 out of 5 on the moisture scale Buoyancy: 4/5 Color: Very black Washability: Mine is washable, rinses with water or oil Odor: Not bad, normal Separation: 3/5 Highlights lashes , but not too strong to make them look sparse, more like thorns, I like that. Length: 4/5 good length, not as big as mascaras that directly target length but still good Volume: 4/5 good volume Clumping: no clumping after 2 coats and sparse plastic bristles. Suitable for application near the roots and for application on the lower lashes. Longevity: Lasts all day without smudging. That is, if you don't rub your eyes all day. Overall I give it 4.5 out of 5 points. Best for people who need lift and volume.