We have tested this product with both the suggested dirty water and water colored with food coloring and it worked on both cases. It should be noted however that the filtering materials are vert small quantities, so using a big amount of water dirt or colors will make it less efficient faster. I would suggest to do the test with small amounts, I think 50 ml is more the enough to demonstrate the principle. For the dyed water I ended up using only 20 ml.My daughter used it for her science project and it was very fun for her to do and she assemble it herself with my guidance to explain the instructions. She is first grade so I do not think it is very challenging bu fun and educating to observe.I added a video of the assembly and the final product and function. I would suggest to use a heavy glass container as a collector as they suggested because it was too flimsy when my daughter used a plastic cup and needed to add a support cup as seen in the end of the video.
Kids Pretend Play Toys Doctor Kit - 37 Piece Educational Toy Dentist Medical Role Play Set For Girls Ages 3-6 By Gifts2U
47 Review
38 Inch Telescoping Handle Insect & Butterfly Net - 12" Ring, 24" Depth | RESTCLOUD
38 Review
FUNERICA 45-Pieces Cutting Pretend Play Food Set, Fruits, Vegetables, Stainless-Steel Pots, Pans, Utensils. Toy Kitchen Accessories Playset For Toddlers Preschoolers Kids (Includes Storage Container)
22 Review
STEM Kit For Boys Ages 8-12, DC Motor Model Car Building Set, Electric Engineering Science Experiment Projects Gift For Kids 8 9 10 11 12
41 Review
CPSYUB Montessori Matching Eggs: Educational Learning Toys For 1-3 Year Old Boys And Girls With Color & Shape Recognition Skills; BPA-Free Easter Eggs Gifts (Set Of 12 Toddler Toys)
33 Review
PicassoTiles 3-In-1 Building Block Set: Rocket, Bus, Train Theme For STEM Learning And Early Education - Magnetic, Pretend Play Toy For Kids
32 Review
MINIBEAR Kids Digital Camera: 40MP, 2.4 Inch Screen, 32GB TF Card - Instant Prints & Selfies For Girls!
40 Review
Baby Einstein Octopus Orchestra Musical Toy, Ages 6 Months +
41 Review