I bought this shoe in gray and I really liked it so I bought it in wine. Knowing the shoes are a little tight, I bought wines half a size larger than usual. I wear 11.5 shoes but bought both colors in 12 and they fit well. Both shoes gave off a strong odor for several weeks, but the wine color wasn't as smelly as the grey. I love the comfort and European style of these shoes so much that I think I will buy the navy blue shoes as well.