I ended up buying a 3rd party controller with super soft curved analog sticks. They eventually wore out and fell apart after about a year of use. I've been looking for replacement covers for a long time, but everything seemed too complicated. Again, I thought they were too big. But they were surprisingly humble. They hold the stick pretty well and haven't slipped after a few hours of use. The only complaint I have is that the texture is a bit rough. I ended up taking sandpaper and started sanding down the bumps until they got a little uncomfortable. But after that I was golden.
VULTURE Rubber Keycaps Cherry MX Double Shot Backlit 18 Keycap Set Compatible For Gaming Mechanical Keyboard OEM Profile Doubleshot Rubberized Diamond Textured Tactile Grip With Key Puller (Pink)
17 Review
Game console Sony PlayStation 3 Slim 3 320 GB HDD, black
74 Review
Protect Your Nintendo Switch Lite With Our 4-In-1 Accessory Kit: Carrying Case, TPU Cover, Screen Protector, And 8 Game Card Slots
21 Review
Upgrade Your Gaming Experience With OSTENT Li-Ion Polymer Battery Pack Replacement For Sony PSP 2000/3000 PSP-S110 Console
11 Review