If the tray is too thin, it won't hold up. If the shelf is too thick, the plastic will break since it doesn't actually move. This is quite a fragile material. I put it on my shelf and immediately clicked on the first one. I was more careful with others after that, but some eventually broke if I tried to move them a little to the right or left. I have metal versions of these that work great and would recommend them instead.
HOMEFORT 5-Tier Wire Shelving Unit, Extra Wide Metal Storage Rack, Free Standing Rack, Durable Organizer Perfect For Pantry Closet Kitchen Laundry Organization In Silver, 29" W X 14" D X 61" H
21 Review
4 Tier Rolling Storage Cart: Perfect For Kitchen, Bathroom & Laundry Room Organization - SOLEJAZZ
25 Review
YITAHOME 10 Drawer Dresser - Fabric Storage Tower For Bedroom, Living Room, Hallway & Closets
20 Review
BLACK LANGRIA 5 Tier Wire Shelving Unit For Supreme Storage Organization And Display
21 Review
Set Of 8 Royexe Storage Cubes With Dual Plastic Handles - Foldable Fabric Bins For Closet Organization And Drawer Storage - Light Grey
29 Review
TerraKing Leaf Bag XL - Heavy Duty Material Collection System For Ride-On Lawnmowers - Fast & Easy Leaf Collection With Nylon Bottom (Fits 3-Bag Hood) [ST95033]
31 Review
6 Pack Black Cloth Storage Bins With Leather Handles And Label Holders - Foldable Cubes Organizer Container Basket Drawers For Bedroom Closet Toys Cubby Bookcase, 10.5"X10.5"X11", MXABS06PLP
51 Review
MaidMAX Storage Bins 12X12X12, For Home Organization And Storage, Toy Storage Cube, Closet Organizers And Storage, With Dual Plastic Handles, Black, Set Of 6
32 Review