I like the feel of the upper on my foot and although the shoe fits very well and has excellent cushioning when walking, my foot slips a bit because the upper is so soft. Now I'm rating them again 4 out of 5 because I still like them but since you order shoes online you don't have time to walk in them so you know what it's like. The style is great and I will keep them but not for what I have planned but definitely for a good everyday work shoe. Review added on November 5th, I haven't been wearing these shows every day, I've been wearing them maybe once a week since May and they're pretty much useless now. The entire bottom of the shoe is broken.