I was skeptical to buy these because there are only 20 purchases and 1 actual review. Got official black and white first. This lasted for a year before one of the fingerprints on the paw faded. I bought these because I wanted all of my controllers to have the same cute paws and I didn't have to pay $10 for each set. For now, this is a great alternative! They are much thinner than the official ones (see photo for comparison) so I would be careful with them as they can tear. but they look so good. I will upgrade hoping they last as long if not longer than the official ones. Update 1: Partner prefers black bumpy sets because they hold the joystick tighter. Others are a bit weaker for them, I don't usually play competitive games so it wasn't a problem to deal with at first.