For the short time they stayed in place they worked great but based on the left trigger they might they be great and be a good alternative to manual operation replacement. Your controller triggers for modified. But unfortunately the included R2 extension didn't snap into place. The left side works great, but the right side falls off every time you pull the trigger. Looking at them side by side, I see that the L2 cover has a noticeably longer piece of plastic that helps secure it in place. They're great if you make them stay, so think about the risk.