Halo 3's Spartan controller is definitely a good buy. If I had another opportunity to buy one, I would buy one. The controller itself is no different than a regular Xbox 360 controller, with the small exception that the surface is smooth with a nice sticker. The controller feels better than other 360 controllers (I have 2 wired, 1 wireless white, 1 wireless green and both Halo 3 limited edition controllers). The smooth surface provides extra grip for 360 degree play and the stickers will make any of your friends take a look. The final plus of this controller is that you get a dainty little Spartan Master Chief action figure. The doll itself is strong enough, not entirely made out of cheap hard fragile plastic. Whether you're buying it for collectibles or because you think it looks cool, it's worth the extra $10.