As happy as I was to get these replacement joysticks, only one of them worked properly. At first I thought it was the way I connected it and it would have to be replaced, but unfortunately that wasn't the case. The red joystick could read left and right well, but up and down just couldn't be read unless it was stuck in that direction or it required some force to move it. Luckily blue works well but a shame only half of the product worked well.