The first one I bought gets 5*. The second was 1/4 inch narrower and slightly thicker than the elastic, 'didn't really work' and would have gotten 1*. So you'll be lucky with which version you get.
π Premium Plastic Collar Stays - Assorted Sizes in Crisp White Finish
9 Review
220 Plastic π Collar Stays for Organized Closet
9 Review
π Ultimate Flexibility with Premium Extender Expandable Elastic America Men's Accessories
9 Review
Stiffs Wurkin: Premium π Assorted Brass Collar for Polished Style
9 Review