I gave this product three. The shoes themselves are five stars. My husband liked her very much. They were nicer shoes but not overly fancy, which was exactly what he needed. However, our excitement evaporated pretty quickly when he put them on and realized something was wrong. After actually looking at the shoes, it turned out that the arch support was uneven. One was completely worn out and the other looked like a brand new shoe, which is how they both should have looked. I sent them back but I will order another pair for him.