I have used both Weaver Nets and Tough 1 Nets on my Tough 1 hay tires. These Weaver nets last three times longer than Tough 1 nets. Both take damage over time and need to be repaired. However, only one of my three Weaver networks had a hole patched in 2 months. My last nets were Tough-1 and they were all repaired so many times that they had to be replaced after 2-3 months (same beasts). To be fair, I love the Tough 1 hay tires, just not the poor quality Tough 1 nets.