Rubber is very thin and doesn't hold its texture well. As well as being a fairly cheap material, rubber isn't abrasion resistant, and when it's sitting on the bottom of your purse you expect it to be able to take a beating. If you buy them, make sure you get them a dark color so dirt and scuffs are less noticeable. These little rubber wallets are also overpriced for what you actually get. I couldn't find them in store so I bought them here. They're not the same material as they used to be, but I think now?
Maxpedition BRK π³ MX218F Gear Micro Wallet
68 Review
Minimalist Slim Wallet Men Women Men's Accessories for Wallets, Card Cases & Money Organizers
51 Review
BRASS TACKS Leathercraft Handmade Blocking Men's Accessories and Wallets, Card Cases & Money Organizers
89 Review
Crabby Wallet Minimalist Pocket Polyester Men's Accessories in Wallets, Card Cases & Money Organizers
59 Review