At best, this shoe fits. I think I bought one of the last pairs in my size so the quality may not be the best. The box they came in looks like it was in a war zone and the shoes didn't look good. I've worn them twice to my office - while the lining on the inside underneath is pulling down the sides and the leather looks very worn. Maybe they just need some skin oil and shine, but I'm not sure. They fit well (and I have a small but wide foot) and I really like the Cuban heel. I received many compliments the first day I put them on. The leather and construction seems very cheap to me, but then again, I didn't pay much for it. I'm definitely willing to try again, maybe with a black pair or a brown pair, but so far I haven't been particularly impressed with the navy ones.