Attention, you can get two shoes of the same size, but one of them is much smaller. I bought a brown pair and a black pair. The brown pair fit me perfectly, but the black pair's left boot is very tight. I figured maybe I just needed to stretch, so I painfully wore them and tried to stretch over time, but it's not just about stretching. Too small. That kills my leg. So today I contacted them to see if they would exchange them for a correct size pair and they said they cannot accept them as they are outside the normal return window and they would apologize for the inconvenience. So my advice is: if you are at risk of buying these shoes, try them on right away and if they don't fit, return them immediately! Because Peltz Shoes doesn't care if you're outside the return window, even though they sent me a shoe saying it's true to size but WAY small. I've been trying to get them back for too long but it takes time to see if they stretch. Peltz Shoes should have provided better service and exchanged shoes.