I've had the same brand of lids for a while and I love them. The old one wore out after a while so I bought the same new one a few days ago. Unfortunately, the new case I received is a detective case. The back of the case cover makes a click when I open and close the cover (see video). I suspect the noise is caused by the bottom wedge touching the back of the laptop lid (see photo). Unfortunately I tried to fix the wedge but it didn't help. Now I can't return it ;-(