I have used Egoway products in the past to replace chargers and my general stance on their products is that they do not last more than 5 months and are not of the highest quality. But I bought from them again because I was in a bind for school and I needed something cheap (emphasis on cheap) to hold out until I can get a real microsoft charger on ebay or something. So the position of the charger is wrong right out of the box. I can plug it in and it won't charge until I move the chord a little. Also, I didn't think it had an indicator light when it's charging. I thought they just didn't wear it, and I didn't think about it too much. But they are the same, and will it sometimes catch fire? Maybe about 3 times out of 10 it lights up. Or a little less like 2.5 out of 10 because in some cases it doesn't burn, especially when the chord is outside of its sweet spot. But for now it works. With a little jiggling, it gets the job done. I can just keep using it to see how long it lasts. If it lasts longer than a year I'll stick with 3 stars. Less than a year old I am only updating this review with 2 stars. Less than 5 months 1 star.