I love these shoes! I only wear Vibram 5 Fingers as I need to feel as much ground as possible due to spinal issues, but this is my first pair with insulation.
I still feel the ground and my feet stay warm and dry!
Pros
Probably should have gone up a size because of the insulation. I wish the black one was my size
Cons
It's good when it's cold and dry. Light rain even if it's 45f and getting cold toes. Dry conditions 25f are also no problem.