Based on one of the reviews here I decided to try them to see if they match my XB One controller mainly because of the color and they are ten bucks cheaper than Control Freaks. If they didn't match at all I couldn't have blamed anyone but myself, but one of them did. I have no idea which is the correct one, but either the PS controller has a larger joystick and one of those things is very tight/just too small, or they have the same joysticks as the Xbox and one of those things is super free. In any case, that's a bad sign for me. If you have ten bucks more, you can choose someone with a decent reputation. However, I need a bit more control precision to play old Doom with the paired controller on my phone.