The shoe itself is good, I gave it a try because the wrong item was sent to me. Ordered the smooth brown grain/white sole and got the cognac/cognac sole added as shown in the picture. The box was the right style, don't know why the shoes in it were different. It's a shame because while these shoes aren't bad, it's not the style I wanted, so a start. half, they are a little narrow in the front for those who might have trouble with a slightly or wider foot.