Ours is installed in a closet. I think it's better for an open wall, it's so strong that it becomes a convenient two-handed operation to get things in and out. Hold the pen with one hand and store or put down the broom or mop with the other hand. It is impractical to do this in a small closet. It has a lot of storage space in a small space, which is nice. We can take it to the garage and buy new cabinet clips.