I have to say these are nice shoes and the fact that they are waterproof is what attracted me, but they are too snug .I usually wear a size 8 in womens shoes and a size 8.5 in on shoes, these 8.5s were still way too narrow and if you look at my photo you can see they are narrower than the white on cloudflyers, which are my absolute favorite and the only shoe I can wear that has helped my plantar fasciitis at all. Even taking the insoles out of these waterproof shoes are still uncomfortable because they have no support. And my sore foot is so stuffed with the insoles that each insole will feel like it.I don't like the crunching sound they make either.I read it in a review and thought hmmm but it's true they crunch when you take a step lol. Overall , if need be to spice it up. and put the space and support they create into the brochure cloud to craft new waterproof shoes! Please! I NEED supportive waterproof shoes by June when we go on vacation! If they weren't crunchy I'd try a size 9 but I'll be returning these uncomfortable noisy shoes for almost $200 and keep looking for other brands I guess :(.