Maybelline New York Classic Eye Makeup Remover - Effective, 4 Fluid Ounce Review

I don't like writing negative reviews. However, it is getting harder and harder to get this product. I was signed up for a subscription and figured I could keep it up. Now it's back on order but looks like it's in stock if you order it the normal way. Also, Maybelline has several different products with containers so similar it's confusing. Some reviews state that the product has changed. I bought the Neutrogena eye makeup remover from Target today and it works just as well. Also about the same

I bought this because a waterproof version was not available so take this review with caution. Doesn't even work on non-waterproof mascara! I have the same effect of soap and water. Its consistency is very strange, like a gel. Buy the waterproof version as it is a much more effective product.

I loved the Maybelline Expert Eye Makeup Remover and have saved 1 bottle for years. I know there's a time limit to doing things, but who knows how many, 5 years from now? I started going downhill and decided to try this one. Uh, that's just awful. I don't care how lightly I try to apply it to my eye, it's like applying a ball of slime. I wish I could return it. Okay, going back to the tiny drips I have left over from the other one.