I gave this a five, because it is a very well-made sturdy beautiful boot, very well-made sturdy boot, lining is soft and would keep your feet very warm. My situation is it's hard to find things that fit, I have an artificial leg on one side oh, and a deformed foot from 47 surgery since birth with spina bifida. Now I have ALS oh, and other people put my shoes on this was too hard to get on my deformed foot I need something that opens all the way almost to the toe. But I gave this a five-star becaSee full review