I've never had much luck with cat treats with my cats. They never seem excited over the treats or run to get them like I've seen cats in ads do, or a few times seen in person with friends' cats. Sometimes, they refuse the treats outright. That didn't happen here. Both my indoor cats and all the outdoor fixed colony strays I tried these with did eat them, but didn't gobble them with excitement. One of my indoor cats is sixteen, and getting harder to tempt to eat. I was hoping he'd love these. SomSee full review