Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Revainrating 5 out of 5
4.8

Comparing Metal Halide, Sodium, and Mercury Vapor High Intensity Discharge Bulbs - How to Choose the Best HID Light for Your Application

Comparing Metal Halide, Sodium, and Mercury Vapor High Intensity Discharge Bulbs - How to Choose the Best HID Light for Your Application

Brighter and Longer Lasting Lighting with HID Bulbs

High intensity discharge (HID) bulbs offer significant advantages over traditional incandescent and fluorescent lighting. The technology behind HID lamps enables them to produce more light per watt and have a significantly longer service life.

Greater Light Output

HID bulbs are up to 4 times more efficient than incandescent bulbs. This greater efficiency results in higher light output:

  • Metal halide HID - up to 115 lumens per watt
  • High pressure sodium HID - up to 150 lumens per watt
  • Incandescent bulb - 10-20 lumens per watt

The higher intensity discharge arc in an HID lamp generates this increased light output. HID bulbs also maintain their original lumen output over their lifespan, whereas incandescent bulbs gradually become dimmer.

Longer Lifespan

The average lifespan of an HID bulb is 10,000 to 20,000 hours, compared to just 1,000 hours for an incandescent. This extended lifespan is due to:

  • Tungsten filament not being used - no burnout or breakage
  • Gas pressure and arc stream regulation maintaining optimal conditions
  • Robust bulb materials and construction
Bulb TypeAverage Lifespan
Standard Incandescent1,000 hours
Halogen Incandescent3,000 hours
CFL (fluorescent)8,000 hours
HID - Metal Halide10,000-20,000 hours
HID - High Pressure Sodium15,000-24,000 hours

High Performance Applications

The intensity and longevity of HID lighting makes it ideal for demanding applications where re-lamping costs and interruptions need to be minimized. Typical uses include:

  • Warehouses
  • Sporting venues
  • Manufacturing facilities
  • Parking lots and outdoor lighting
  • Streetlights

When lighting costs and maintenance are critical factors, HID lamps offer superior illumination over standard bulb options. Their higher lumen output, consistent lighting levels over life, and extended operation result in lower operating expenses over the long run.

Why HID Bulbs Are Better Than Traditional Bulbs

When it comes to lighting performance and value, high-intensity discharge (HID) bulbs offer significant advantages over old-fashioned incandescent and fluorescent lighting. By understanding the benefits, you can make informed decisions for your home or business lighting needs.

More Light Output

HID bulbs produce a greater amount of light per watt compared to traditional bulbs:

  • A 400W metal halide HID produces 36,000 lumens.
  • A comparable 400W high pressure sodium HID produces 50,000 lumens.
  • A 400W incandescent bulb only produces 4,800 lumens.

That's up to 10 times as much light output from HID technology! This increased efficiency makes HID the top choice for large commercial and industrial spaces like warehouses, gymnasiums, and parking garages.

Longer Lifespan

Rather than using a fragile filament, HID bulbs generate light through an arc discharge in a sealed gas medium. This results in an average bulb lifespan of 10,000-24,000 hours compared to just 1,000 hours for an incandescent:

  • The City of Phoenix found high pressure sodium streetlights lasted 4-5 years compared to just 1 year for incandescent bulbs, saving on maintenance costs.
  • Retrofitting a warehouse with 400W HID fixtures rather than 400W halogens would mean replacing bulbs every 2 years instead of every 3-4 months.

Better Color Properties

HID lighting provides better color rendering and temperature options than old incandescent bulbs:

  • High pressure sodium HIDs offer a warm tone perfect for outdoor lighting.
  • Metal halide HIDs come in cool or neutral white hues for a crisp, bright light.
  • Incandescents have poor color rendering and a warm, yellow/orange glow.

This makes HID a great choice for applications where color accuracy and vision are important, like sports facilities and commercial spaces.

For superior performance, value, and return on investment, high intensity discharge bulbs outshine traditional lighting. Their higher efficiency, longer life, and excellent lighting properties make HID the go-to solution for large, demanding lighting applications.

How HID Bulb Technology Works

High intensity discharge (HID) lamps operate differently than traditional incandescent bulbs. By generating light through an arc discharge between two electrodes, HID bulbs offer greater efficiency and intensity.

HID Bulb Anatomy

HID bulbs contain:

  • Two tungsten electrodes inside a quartz glass arc tube
  • Inert gas and metals/salts to generate the light arc
  • A ballast to regulate electrical current

Generating the Arc Discharge

When power is applied, an electric arc jumps between the two electrodes:

  1. Current flows through the starter electrode first, ionizing the gas mixture inside the arc tube.
  2. The arc strikes across to the second main electrode, heating the metallic salts/vapors.
  3. These materials give off photons, generating intense light.

Maintaining the Arc

Once struck, the arc discharge is maintained and regulated via:

  • Control of gas pressure inside the arc tube
  • Precise positioning and separation of electrodes
  • Ballast regulating the current

These factors allow the arc to operate at optimal temperature and efficiency.

HID Lamp Types

Different HID bulb types use specific gas mixtures to produce their characteristic light:

  • Metal Halide - Argon, krypton, xenon, mercury, and metal halides create bright white light.
  • High Pressure Sodium - Xenon, sodium amalgam, and mercury vapors result in golden yellow light.
  • Mercury Vapor - Mainly just mercury vapor, producing bluish-green light.

Understanding the internal workings of HID bulbs allows matching the technology to lighting needs. Proper fixture design ensures optimal bulb performance.

How HID Lighting Handles Heavy-Use Requirements

High intensity discharge (HID) lamps possess performance characteristics making them ideal for facilities and spaces with high lighting demands.

Extreme Environments

HID bulbs thrive under conditions that cause other bulbs to fail prematurely:

  • High bay fixtures in warehouses need to withstand dust and impacts from forklifts.
  • Parking lot lights experience large temperature swings and vibrations.
  • Gymnasium and stadium lights require moisture resistance.

The quartz glass arc tube and rugged filament electrodes allow HID bulbs to operate reliably despite these challenges.

24/7 Operation

Facilities like hospitals, data centers, and public spaces need constant illumination. With lifespans up to 24,000 hours, HID lamps can burn for years without replacement:

  • HID streetlights may only need replacement every 4-5 years compared to incandescent bulbs burning out yearly.
  • HID bulbs in a 24-hour industrial facility will outlast metal halide and fluorescent lights 2-3 times over.

This minimizes maintenance interruptions and re-lamping labor expenses.

High Lumens and Efficiency

Large commercial and public venues depend on HID lighting's high output:

  • A 400W metal halide HID produces 36,000 lumens, compared to just 5,000 for a 400W high bay fluorescent.
  • Stadiums fitted with 1000W metal halide HID fixtures achieve crisp, bright lighting for sports broadcast in high definition.

Lower energy use for equivalent lumen levels also makes HID cost effective.

Safety and Security

HID lamps play an important role in safety:

  • Mercury vapor HID lot lights deter crime with high color rendition and zero dark restart time.
  • Sodium vapor HID highway lights improve visibility in inclement weather.

Durable, high intensity HID lighting provides 24/7 protection and visibility where it's needed most.

From versatility to high performance, HID technology can handle the toughest lighting challenges.

Picking the Best HID Bulb Type for Your Needs

When selecting a high intensity discharge (HID) bulb, factors like color temperature, color rendering, and lumen output should be considered to match the bulb to your specific lighting application.

Comparing Major HID Bulb Types

HID BulbLight ColorCRILumensBest Use
Metal HalideCrisp White65-9060-115 lm/WRetail, stadiums
High Pressure SodiumGolden Yellow22-6580-150 lm/WStreetlights, security
Mercury VaporBlue-Green15-6525-60 lm/WIndustrial areas

Color Temperature

Metal halide ranges from cool (4000K) to warm (3000K). High pressure sodium is very warm at 2100K. Choose based on desired tone.

CRI - Color Rendering

Higher CRI (80-90+) ensures colors are displayed accurately. Important for retail and workspaces. Lower CRI (25-65) is acceptable for outdoor and security lighting.

Lumen Output

Check fixture specifications and space requirements. Gyms and warehouses need high lumen HID bulbs like metal halide and high pressure sodium.

Location and Hours of Use

  • High pressure sodium lights parking lots and streets well for long nighttime hours.
  • Metal halide illuminates commercial and industrial spaces during business hours.

Choose Bulb and Fixture Together

Ensure the fixture is designed for the HID bulb type. Pairing the wrong HID bulb with a fixture can lead to subpar performance and shorter lifespans.

With the right HID bulb for your lighting needs, you'll get optimal illumination and value. Consult an expert if unsure about making the best match.

How Metal Halide, Sodium, and Mercury Vapor HID Bulbs Differ

High intensity discharge (HID) bulbs utilize different gases and vapors to produce various colors and lighting properties. Comparing the most common types - metal halide, high pressure sodium, and mercury vapor - can help determine the best HID bulb for an application.

Metal Halide HID Bulbs

  • Produce bright, white light from 4000K (cool) to 3000K (warm)
  • Good color rendering index (CRI) of 65-90
  • 60-115 lumens per watt efficacy
  • Ideal for retail, hospitals, warehouses, gyms, stadiums

High Pressure Sodium HID Bulbs

  • Emit yellow/golden light at around 2100K
  • Lower CRI of 22-65
  • Very high efficacy of 80-150 lumens per watt
  • Used for streetlights, security lighting, industrial spaces

Mercury Vapor HID Bulbs

  • Produce blue-green light due to mercury gas emission
  • CRI ranging from 15-65
  • 25-60 lumens per watt efficacy
  • Primarily used in industrial settings
Bulb TypeProsCons
Metal HalideGreat color properties, high CRI and neutral white lightLower efficacy than sodium, requires warm-up
High Pressure SodiumVery high efficacy and lumens, low operating costsPoor color rendering, warm yellow light
Mercury VaporLong life, low acquisition costLow CRI and lumens, outdated technology

Evaluate lighting needs, space use, hours of operation, and energy costs when deciding between these common HID bulb types.

Purchasing HID Bulbs with an Amazon Prime Membership

Amazon Prime provides fast, free shipping on millions of items, along with other benefits like streaming media content. This membership program can be useful when purchasing specialty items like high intensity discharge (HID) bulbs for commercial and industrial lighting applications.

Prime Shipping Benefits

Many HID bulbs and fixtures qualify for Prime's free two-day shipping. This allows faster delivery times compared to standard shipping methods. For time-sensitive projects or urgent replacements, two-day shipping can be advantageous.

Prime members also get access to Prime Day deals, exclusive offers, and discounts on HID lighting equipment. Subscribing to Prime just for a major one-time purchase of bulk HID bulbs and fixtures can provide considerable savings to offset the membership cost.

HID Selection on Amazon

Amazon stocks a wide range of HID bulb types and brands, including Philips, Sylvania, GE, and specialty manufacturers. There are options for common wattages and bases like mogul and medium sockets. Amazon has metal halide, high pressure sodium, and other HID varieties.

The selection makes it easy to get replacement bulbs for existing fixtures. And HID fixtures and ballasts are also available through Amazon's marketplace sellers.

A Prime membership can provide fast, free shipping and exclusive discounts on HID lighting supplies. Check any membership terms and conditions to ensure appropriate use.

Understanding The Basics Of Gas Discharge Lamps

Gas-discharge lamps are artificial light sources that generate light by sending an electric discharge through an ionized gas, a plasma. They typically use noble gases or a mixture of these gases, along with additional substances like mercury, sodium, and metal halides. Gas-discharge lamps offer higher efficiency than incandescent lamps, but are more complicated to manufacture and require auxiliary electronic equipment such as ballasts to control current flow through the gas. They also have a perceivable start-up time to achieve their full light output. The discharge lamps work on the fundamental principle that light is emitted when electrons have collided with each other. There are different types of gas discharge lamps available, with essential parameters like output power and pulse durations varying by orders of magnitude.


Comments (0)

Please, sign in to write a comment