So I LOVE these shoes. As others have often pointed out, their soles are worn out. I wear them on average 3 days a week. I'm not up to holes in the soles, but very close. I received these at the end of March, now at the beginning of July. I wasn't thrilled that you can't remove and change the insole, but with wear they are loose enough that I will pull them out. and try my other insoles. I will also make sure they are replaced with better soles unless it would cost too much. Leather is in excellent condition. I have a wider than average foot and this shoe was comfortable right from the start. I'm not ready to give them up yet! 4 stars would have been 5 if the sole had lasted longer. I'm not sure I would buy them again, but I might if the cost of repairing the sole is too high. UPDATE: 4/17/17: These shoes are officially discontinued. They were simply used up too quickly. You can't recover them, you just have to throw them away. Too bad because they were so comfortable. I didn't buy them again. No star change. I could buy them again and wear less, but even the printing seems silly.