To be honest they didn't impress me one bit. I'm not sure I understand why the alligator clip in the tie clip that the promotional insert talked about is so undesirable. I found these clips a little stiff and difficult to open at first and wonder how long they will last if I have to open them every time I put them on. I didn't find it too big and it was a secure fit. These clips do the job and look beautiful. I liked that it comes in a 3 pack with black, silver and gold clips.