Originally "Hey Dude" bought shoes. Tried it and it was just cheap. Too small so I decided to try a larger size. I saw these shoes when ordering, so I ordered both. Hey dude, fitted well but my finger came out at the top like there was so little fabric. Also, it wasn't as comfortable as advertised. Fine. Like a slipper I guess. Meanwhile, this shoe was amazing. Good support, nice material, wide toe box. Also, the insole was removable so I could add extra support. I love her and highly recommend her.