I choose this one as it keeps the controllers clean and tidy. Love the fact that I put a little plug in the controller and forget about it. My sons messed up the charging cable that came with the PS4 and I'm sure if I had a cable that required them to plug it in they would bend the connection, break it or even not plug it in. This system allows me to plug in and the guys just pop the controllers into the charger wherever they go. It has worked well enough so far so I bought a second one as my wife loves that it keeps the controllers clean.