I've always considered New Balance sneakers to be the most comfortable running shoes out of the box. The only thing I went up based on other reviews is half a size (9->9.5).
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico Shoes - Men's Grey Sneakers
46 Review
Orange Men's Vibram Ascent Insulated M Sneaker Shoes - Enhanced SEO
45 Review
Steve Madden Fashion Sneaker Fabric Men's Shoes for Fashion Sneakers
54 Review
π― Experience Maximum Comfort with New Balance MX624V2 Men's Training Shoes
45 Review