Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Kevin Lawson photo
Mongolia, Ulaanbaatar
1 Level
791 Review
79 Karma

Review on ๐Ÿ’พ Seagate STEL6000100 Backup Plus Hub 6TB External Hard Drive Desktop HDD with USB 3.0 and Bonus Adobe CC Photography by Kevin Lawson

Revainrating 1 out of 5

At least it failed during the warranty period.

The drive booted up fine and I was able to migrate everything from my two 5TB drives, but it started silently corrupting about 10% of my data. I first noticed my backup fail and have since replaced everything but the hard drive to find the problem. SMART still says the disk is fine and I have no problem reading it, but it consistently writes the wrong bit and doesn't tell me. Methodology: I document the source drive, destination drive, cables and computer, copy a few gigabytes of files, then use Doublekiller to remove the duplicates and HxD to compare what's left. I see 10-30% of my files get corrupted with a little difference when the 8TB drive is the target, on 2 different USB 3.0 sticks, 3 different computers and 6 different source files. Several times it just skipped the last part of the file and wrote all 0's. Unfortunately my 5TB Backup Plus failed right out of warranty. I have backups, but it's already cost me a week to diagnose.

Pros
  • There's something in there
Cons
  • There are even more interesting options.