Review on 🚭 Smokeless Car Ashtray - Stainless Steel, Windproof and Large Cigarette Ash Tray for Outdoor or Car Use - Convenient Ash Holder for Smokers with Automatic Extinguishing Feature by Devin Jirsa

So far I like this ashtray. It's big enough to be clicked on while driving without looking, and the butt hole is big enough that I don't have to strain to put it in. The only drawback, which I only gave 4 stars, is that you have to constantly shake the ashtray so that the ash actually falls into it. Shaking will fly some of the ash out, and if you don't shake it, the ash will be all over your car. If they could solve this one small problem it would be easy for a 5 star product. Update I had to deduct a star. Ash that doesn't fall into the hole can make a mess if you're not careful. Even worse, the lid isn't completely secure after some use and washing. When you tap, the lid will pop off and a trickle of ash will fly out. A steeper slope and maybe a thread to hold the tip would make this ideal.