I bought 9.5 EW for my daughter who wears outdoor shoes about the same size. Based on the comments I thought they wouldn't fit, but they fit - perfectly. Maybe adding width helped, but this pair was true to size.
Capezio Girls 3800 Mary Jane Tap Shoe in Caramel - Size 11.5 M Toddlers
49 Review
Felix Flora Toddler Flower Dress Shoes - Adorable and Comfy Flats
47 Review
Dance in Style with Molly Jane Tap Shoes: Unisex-Child Mary Flats
50 Review
Adorable Blowfish Malibu Play-t for Toddler and Little Girls
47 Review