I would have rated a 5 star, but rated as 4, because of the heel height on the back of the shoe. It rides too low. The shoe is great! They are comfortable. I expect the heel part will be smooshed and flattened after a month or so. The back is soft which will further increase the likelihood of slipping off the heel sooner than later. Love them otherwise! I’d take the chance and at least try them for yourself.