Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Anthony Morrow photo
1 Level
748 Review
69 Karma

Review on πŸ–¨οΈ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series by Anthony Morrow

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Updates: HP58A toner greatly improves total page count.

My second and probably last update: According to the latest information on my Laserjet consumables, I will print over 3,000 pages with my current toner. That's great. So I've concluded that the HP replacement toner I installed on January 18, 2020 shows the number of pages printed as advertised by HP. Thanks HP! My first update: I printed a total of 1598 pages. The HP supplies status page says I have 850 more pages to go. I know the rest of the page estimator is very conservative about raising user expectations and then disappointing them. So I think I'll end up with about 3,000 toner pages. This is excellent so I increased the stars to 5. Original post: The toner that came with the HP MFP M428fdw printer (which I bought from Revain) lasted 3,200 pages. The printer description says that the toner that came with it was full toner (not "starter" toner). I was pleasantly surprised to get 3200 pages out of it. Then I ordered a new toner from Revain. I've already printed about 956 pages with it. The HP supplies status page says I have 1,250 pages left. That means I get about 2206 pages with this toner. That's about 33% less than the toner that came with the printer. Not good. I'll wait and see how it goes. 2.5 stars so far. I will keep you up-to-date.

Pros
  • Confident
Cons
  • Out of fashion