Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
🖨️ hp 58a (cf258a) black toner cartridge for hp laserjet pro m404 & m428 series logo

🖨️ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series Review

5

·

Average

Revainrating 3.5 out of 5  
Rating 
3.6
💻 Office Electronics Accessories, 💼 Accessories & Supplies

View on AmazonView on ЯM

Media

(4)
img 1 attached to 🖨️ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series
img 2 attached to 🖨️ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series
img 3 attached to 🖨️ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series
img 4 attached to 🖨️ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series

Description of 🖨️ HP 58A (CF258A) Black Toner Cartridge for HP LaserJet Pro M404 & M428 Series

HP 58A toner cartridges work with HP printers: HP LaserJet Pro M404dn, M404dw, M404n, HP LaserJet Pro M428fdn, M428fdw. Original HP toner cartridges produce an average of 71% more usable pages than non-HP cartridges. HP 58A cartridge yield (approx.): 3,000 pages. HP 58A toner is designed to work with your HP printer for high quality, reliable results every print. What's in the box: 1 New Original HP 58A (CF258A) toner cartridge. Color: Black. Original HP toner cartridges: genuine toner for your HP printer.

Reviews

Global ratings 5
  • 5
    2
  • 4
    0
  • 3
    2
  • 2
    1
  • 1
    0

Type of review

Revainrating 3 out of 5

Approximately 1000 sheets printed, then blank. :(

I bought this with the printer. I replaced the starter toner when it ran out, which was a month ago. The starter toner that came with the printer has Lasted about as long as 1000. VERY disappointed with the toner life Update - Print quality has been set to the highest toner consumption option.

Pros
  • Color: Black
Cons
  • Updates

Revainrating 5 out of 5

The outside of the packaging is not very good but the inside is fine

Not very happy with the delivery condition. Looks repackaged. However, once I opened it with a phone support service and after a full inspection everything is fine! Inside, the clear cartridge seals and installation instructions were intact. It also includes a recycle label sticker. The printer indicated that a genuine HP cartridge was installed, so everything is fine!

Pros
  • HP 58A cartridge Yield (approx.): 3000 pages
Cons
  • Not bad, but...

Revainrating 2 out of 5

Poor quality and durability for the price

Attention! I started buying this model and last ordered to the office in December: Delivered on 12/14. Ended on January 11th. For a small office for two? No way. We certainly don't print THAT much. I used to buy counterfeit toners until the HP chip had to be taken out and put back in - that didn't work for us. HP STOP BEING GREED AND MAKE A PRODUCT WITH HIGHER AVAILABILITY, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU NEED TO REPLACE IT MONTHLY!

Pros
  • Decent performance
Cons
  • Other Other

Revainrating 3 out of 5

Poor value for money

I don't know what the printer cost to cartridge cost ratio should be, but 43% seems high. Men know how Gillett gives away a razor and then charges $20 for a dozen blades. The same applies to inkjet printers. Luckily there are suppliers who offer cartridges with a share of about 15%. In any case, I had to buy this cartridge because HP, in its boundless greed, included a chip with the cartridge and non-original cartridges without a chip do not work. So now every time I put in a new aftermarket…

Pros
  • Good product for the price
Cons
  • poor

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Updates: HP58A toner greatly improves total page count.

My second and probably last update: According to the latest information on my Laserjet consumables, I will print over 3,000 pages with my current toner. That's great. So I've concluded that the HP replacement toner I installed on January 18, 2020 shows the number of pages printed as advertised by HP. Thanks HP! My first update: I printed a total of 1598 pages. The HP supplies status page says I have 850 more pages to go. I know the rest of the page estimator is very conservative about raising…

Pros
  • Confident
Cons
  • Out of fashion