I love these loafers, they look subtle and can be worn with nicer casual outfits. I really like the insole as it offers a good level of support and stiffness without being uncomfortable. However, I found that the shoes were too narrow for me and the heel can sometimes rub. I see it's currently on sale for $36, which is great value. For the list price of $70 I would say this is a 4 star product although if you find it on sale it is definitely worth considering.