This shoe is slightly larger than expected. I ordered 9 but maybe 8.5 would be more suitable. The elastic slit allows the shoe to stretch as you walk, which can increase the feeling of being oversized. But for a return/exchange I don't think it's that bad. I like the leather sole. The lining is comfortable and the shoes are easy to put on. Shoes in general are nice and simple but not of the best quality. It's good, not great.