For almost a decade I have been very satisfied with the Johnston & Murphy Ainsworth Men's Penny Slip-On Loafers as they are comfortable, affordable and convenient were utterly unhappy and grew to the point that it could only be ordered from the MFG website for more than double what I had previously paid. Ultimately this is my choice. I won't lie, it's only 90% percent. It's *slightly* less comfortable and fits a little less, but the price is right. Important: I used a shoe size "9" from Johnston & Murphy, so I need a "10". I've tried both "10.5" and "10W" but the normal "10" is the closest. These are good shoes when they fit.