Replacement bumpers work well and it's nice to get an extra kit plus screwdriver for the same price. However, the tiny holes on the replacement parts are in a different part of the controller (the casing around the Xbox Guide button) and both of my replacement parts were too small. I took a 1/16 diameter drill bit and drilled holes to make them a little bigger. I didn't use a drill, I just twisted the drill in my fingers and it worked.