The first two pairs, one black, one cognac, previously bought and looked at, fell out. Size 12XW. The third pair should be "Crazy Horse" but it doesn't look like the picture on the web or any other picture. The bodice is a smooth brown (see my photo) and not striped or mottled as shown in the image online. But there are no obvious flaws, they fit the same and they have a small rawhide tongue at the top of the heel. These are exactly the same shoes, just with a different finish. And I must say that I like the look of what was delivered better than what is shown in the picture. I can't give 5 stars because if the picture doesn't fit, it's usually a fatal flaw. Maybe I would give six stars, but I can't either. So let's just say it ends well, all's well. And keep an eye out if the Spotted/Smooth/Rawhide combo is a must-have for you. Maybe you understand, maybe not. Not me.