Review on Mighty Paw Waterproof Alternative Smell Proof by Jim Larson

Fits perfectly, size does not slip. The line hook is very durable which is great. Cleans up very easily and you can avoid the swelling and stench that comes with wet fabric collars. My only complaint is that after a few months and the start of the dirty season the reflective tape has worn off. It's a bit of a shame and definitely not aesthetically pleasing, but it's also pretty reasonable that anything applied to the (really awesome) collar elastic will eventually peel off. The structural integrity of the collar is still there, it just didn't take long for it to start looking worn. (Be aware that my dog prefers to be outside in the mud, water, and snow to play with other dogs more than 6 hours a day and you may not see this rapid wear and tear in a more sedentary dog or a dog that wears a collar part-time.)