The shape and light of the cylindrical frosted lamp is great! However, I ordered the frosted version because I want the bare bulb to be visible in the chandelier. Unfortunately, it glows with 6 separate bright spots instead of a nice even glow (unlike most dull LED bulbs). So it has a more whimsical sci-fi feel than I wanted. I would still recommend them for lamps where the bare bulb isn't visible, or if you don't care if the light is even across the bulb.