The quality is at the highest level, be sure to try it.
The gamepad is a magnet for grime, regardless of how clean your hands are. As a result, I think you should go with the black choice.
Pros
Positives: Nice jangling; Grip is soft; Construction is sturdy. Beautiful design; gyroscope and touch panel included; no creaking or backlash when used; adaptive triggers (may not function with all games).
Cons
You can get controllers that feature a floating analog stick.